Quiet FiringConstructive DismissalPerformance ReviewsEmployment Standards ActReprisal

"Could This Be Considered Quiet Firing?" What Ontario Law Actually Calls It

Sudden bad reviews, a surprise PIP, shrinking hours, meetings you stopped being invited to. Ontario law has no offence called "quiet firing," but it has three names for what may be happening to you, and one of them can mean you are already terminated and owed a package.

Written By: Daniel Carter|Reviewed By: Amir Mirza
Updated: August 2026
An Ontario office worker reading a performance review at a desk, with an empty meeting room visible behind them

Key takeaways

  • "Quiet firing" is not a cause of action in Ontario. The legal names for it are constructive dismissal, a statutory layoff under ESA s. 56, and reprisal, and each has a different test and a different forum.
  • A harsh review or a PIP on its own is rarely a dismissal. What converts it is a real change to pay, hours, duties, reporting line or status, judged objectively (Farber v. Royal Trust Co., [1997] 1 SCR 846).
  • Cutting your hours can terminate you by operation of statute. Under ESA s. 56(3.1) a week where you earn less than half your regular pay counts as a layoff week, and 13 such weeks in 20 blows past the temporary layoff limit in s. 56(2)(a).
  • Timing is evidence. If the sudden negative reviews followed an ESA inquiry, a leave, a safety complaint or a request for accommodation, ESA s. 74(2) and OHSA s. 50(5) put the burden of proof on the employer, not on you.
  • Do not resign to make a point. ESA s. 56(1)(b) only counts a resignation made "within a reasonable period," so waiting too long can sink the claim and quitting too fast without advice can hand the employer a free exit.
In this article

✅Quick answer. Ontario law has no offence called "quiet firing," so the question is not whether it fits the label but which legal name it fits. If your duties, hours, pay, reporting line or status actually changed, that is constructive dismissal territory under ESA s. 56(1)(b) and the test in Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10. If they simply cut your hours or shifts, ESA s. 56(1)(c) may already have terminated you by operation of statute, backdated to the first day. If the cold shoulder started right after you asked about your rights, took a leave, reported a hazard or asked for accommodation, that is reprisal, and the employer carries the burden of proof.

What does "quiet firing" actually mean under Ontario law?

It means nothing on its own. "Quiet firing" is a workplace word for an employer making the job worse until you resign, which saves them a severance package. No Ontario statute uses the term and no court has to decide whether your situation qualifies for it. What a court or the Ministry will ask is narrower: did the employer change a fundamental term of your job, or punish you for using a legal right?

That reframing matters, because it changes what you should be writing down. Nobody wins a case by proving their manager was cold. People win by proving that on a specific date the work, the pay, the hours, the reporting line or the title changed, and that they did not agree to it.

What you are experiencingThe legal name for itWhat it takes to succeed
Duties stripped, projects reassigned, you report to someone junior nowConstructive dismissalA substantial unilateral change to an essential term, judged objectively
Shifts or hours cut, pay reducedDeemed termination by layoff, ESA s. 56(1)(c), or constructive dismissalUnder 50 per cent of regular weekly earnings for more than 13 weeks in 20, per ESA s. 56(2)(a) and s. 56(3.1)
Excluded from meetings, frozen out, no work assignedConstructive dismissal, second branch of PotterA course of conduct showing the employer no longer intends to be bound by the contract
Reviews turned negative right after you asked about pay, took a leave or filed a complaintReprisal, ESA s. 74, OHSA s. 50, Code s. 8A protected activity plus a penalty; the employer must then prove it was not the reason
Negative treatment tied to disability, age, pregnancy, race, creed or family statusDiscrimination, Human Rights Code s. 5A protected ground, adverse treatment, and a connection between them
Manager is simply unpleasant and nothing else changedUsually nothing actionableThere is no standalone tort of harassment in Ontario

Is a sudden bad performance review or a PIP enough on its own?

Usually not by itself. Employers are entitled to manage, to criticize, to set targets and to document. A first bad review after five good ones is powerful evidence, but a review is a piece of paper, not a change to your contract. What converts it into something legally actionable is what rides along with it: a pay cut, lost hours, removed duties, a demotion, or a penalty for something you were legally entitled to do.

So the honest answer to "could this be considered quiet firing" is that the review is the symptom worth reading, not the injury worth suing over. Read it for what it discloses. A performance improvement plan with impossible targets, no support, and a 30-day deadline tells you what the employer intends. A sudden pattern of written warnings for things nobody was ever warned about before tells you a file is being built.

  • A review that criticizes work you were never told was a problem, from a manager who never raised it in one-on-ones.
  • Targets that were not in your job description, or that no peer is being held to.
  • A PIP that removes your best accounts, territory or files first, then measures you on results.
  • Documentation that appears in your file weeks after the events, sometimes backdated in tone if not in date.
  • A review that arrives days or weeks after you asked about overtime, requested accommodation, booked a leave, or reported a hazard.

If the employer is building a cause file, remember two things. First, cause is contextual and proportionate: McKinley v. BC Tel, 2001 SCC 38 rejected the idea that any misconduct automatically justifies dismissal. Second, even where cause is made out at common law, statutory entitlements can still be owed: Render v. ThyssenKrupp Elevator (Canada) Limited, 2022 ONCA 310 is the reminder that the common law standard and the ESA standard are not the same standard.

When does it cross the line into constructive dismissal?

When the employer unilaterally changes something essential, or behaves in a way that shows it is done being bound by your contract. Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10 sets out two branches, and you only need one. The test is objective, not about how upset you are: Farber v. Royal Trust Co., [1997] 1 SCR 846 asks whether a reasonable person in the same situation would have felt the essential terms were being substantially changed.

  • Branch one: a unilateral breach of an essential term of the contract that is substantial. Pay, hours, duties, reporting structure, location and status are the usual candidates.
  • Branch two: a course of conduct that, taken as a whole, shows the employer no longer intends to be bound by the contract. This is the branch that catches freezing-out, sidelining, and death by a thousand cuts, where no single act would be enough.

Branch two is the one most quiet firing situations live in, and it is the one that rewards a diary. Individually, being dropped from a weekly meeting is nothing. Fourteen entries across four months, next to a stripped territory and a frozen salary, is a pattern a court can see.

If the employer has told you a term is changing going forward, Wronko v. Western Inventory Service Ltd., 2008 ONCA 327 sets out your three options: accept the change, reject it and sue for constructive dismissal, or tell the employer clearly that you reject it and continue working, in which case the employer must either back down or terminate you on proper notice. What you must not do is say nothing for a long time and keep collecting the reduced pay, because silence starts to look like agreement. More on that in condonation and changed job duties.

If they cut my hours or shifts, am I already terminated under the ESA?

Quite possibly, and this is the most overlooked route in a quiet firing case. ESA s. 56(1)(c) says an employer terminates the employment of an employee if "the employer lays the employee off for a period longer than the period of a temporary lay-off." A cut in hours can be a layoff even though you are still on the schedule, because s. 56(3.1) measures layoff by earnings, not by whether you were told to stay home.

Start with s. 56(1). There are three limbs, and only one has to fit: (a) the employer "dismisses the employee or otherwise refuses or is unable to continue employing him or her"; (b) the employer "constructively dismisses the employee and the employee resigns from his or her employment in response to that within a reasonable period"; and (c) the employer "lays the employee off for a period longer than the period of a temporary lay-off." In a quiet firing fact pattern, (a) rarely applies because nobody has said the word fired. Limb (b) is the constructive dismissal route above. Limb (c) is the sleeper.

Now s. 56(3.1), which does the heavy lifting. If you have a regular work week, you are laid off for a week if "(a) in that week, the employee earns less than one-half the amount he or she would earn at his or her regular rate in a regular work week; and (b) the week is not an excluded week." Under s. 56(3), an "excluded week" is a week where for one or more days you were not able to work, not available for work, subject to a disciplinary suspension, or not provided with work because of a strike or lock-out. So a week you were off sick does not count against the employer, but under s. 56(3.2) it still counts toward the 20, 52 or 78 week measuring window.

Then walk the definition of temporary layoff in s. 56(2), because every limb that does not apply narrows the employer's defence:

  • s. 56(2)(a): "a lay-off of not more than 13 weeks in any period of 20 consecutive weeks." This is the ordinary cap. Thirteen weeks under half pay inside a 20 week window, and the layoff stops being temporary.
  • s. 56(2)(b): more than 13 weeks but less than 35 weeks in 52, and only if one of six conditions holds: (i) you continue to receive substantial payments from the employer, (ii) the employer keeps paying into a legitimate retirement or pension plan or a legitimate group or employee insurance plan, (iii) you receive supplementary unemployment benefits, (iv) you are employed elsewhere and would qualify for those benefits but for that, (v) the employer recalls you within the time approved by the Director, or (vi) for a non-union employee, the employer recalls you within the time set out in an agreement between you and the employer. In a quiet firing case, employers rarely satisfy any of these, because there is no recall agreement and no supplementary benefit scheme.
  • s. 56(2)(c): applies only to an employee represented by a trade union, with recall within the time set out in an agreement between the employer and the union. It fails if you are not in a union.
  • s. 56(2)(d): applies only to a non-union employee, only where the layoff is 35 or more weeks in 52 but less than 52 weeks in 78, and only where both (i) the employer recalls you within the time set out in an agreement between you and the employer, and (ii) the employer has obtained an approval for an extended lay-off from the Director under subsection 66.1(6). Both conditions are required. An employer that quietly cut your hours without ever signing a recall agreement or applying to the Director cannot rely on this.

If you do not have a regular work week, the ESA measures you against your own history instead. Under s. 56(3.3), you are laid off beyond a temporary layoff if for more than 13 weeks in any 20 consecutive weeks you earn "less than one-half the average amount he or she earned per week in the period of 12 consecutive weeks that preceded the 20-week period." Section 56(3.4) says an excluded week is not counted in the 13 but is counted in the 20, and that if the 12 week baseline contains an excluded week, the average is calculated using only the non-excluded weeks. Sections 56(3.5) and (3.6) apply the same machinery at 35 weeks in 52, and s. 56(3.7) and (3.8) at 52 weeks in 78. These subsections do not apply at all if you have a regular work week; s. 56(3.1) governs instead.

Two closing subsections matter enormously in practice. Section 56(4) says an employer who lays an employee off "without specifying a recall date shall not be considered to terminate the employment of the employee, unless the period of the lay-off exceeds that of a temporary lay-off." That is the employer's shelter, and it expires. And s. 56(5) says that where employment is terminated under clause (1)(c), "the employment shall be deemed to be terminated on the first day of the lay-off." Your termination date is backdated to the first reduced week, which affects your notice calculation and your limitation clock. See reduced pay or hours and temporary layoff as constructive dismissal.

Does the same reduction trigger ESA severance pay?

It can, but the threshold is different and the qualifying conditions are stricter. ESA s. 63(1) lists five ways an employer severs employment, and s. 63(2.1) uses a one-quarter earnings test rather than the one-half test used for termination. Severance pay also carries separate eligibility requirements based on length of service and employer payroll, which sit elsewhere in the Act, so severance is never automatic just because s. 63(1) is met.

  • s. 63(1)(a): the employer "dismisses the employee or otherwise refuses or is unable to continue employing the employee."
  • s. 63(1)(b): the employer "constructively dismisses the employee and the employee resigns from his or her employment in response within a reasonable period." Same reasonable period requirement as s. 56(1)(b).
  • s. 63(1)(c): the employer "lays the employee off for 35 or more weeks in any period of 52 consecutive weeks," or beyond the expiry of a Director-approved extended layoff.
  • s. 63(1)(d): a layoff because of "a permanent discontinuance of all of the employer's business at an establishment." This limb does not apply to a quiet firing; the business is still running, which is why you are still being scheduled.
  • s. 63(1)(e): you resign during the statutory notice period after giving at least two weeks written notice, in which case s. 63(3) deems severance to have occurred on the day the employer's notice would have taken effect. This also does not apply unless the employer has already given you formal notice of termination.

For the layoff limb, s. 63(2.1) says an employee with a regular work week is laid off for a week if "(a) in that week, the employee earns less than one-quarter the amount he or she would earn at his or her regular rate in a regular work week; and (b) the week is not an excluded week," with "excluded week" defined in s. 63(2) identically to s. 56(3). Section 63(2.2) counts excluded weeks toward the 52 or 78 week window. Section 63(2.3) applies the one-quarter test to employees without a regular work week, measured against the average of the preceding 12 consecutive weeks, at 35 weeks in 52 under (a) and 52 weeks in 78 under (b), and s. 63(2.4) handles excluded weeks in the same way as s. 56(3.4).

The practical point: a reduction that leaves you at 40 per cent of normal pay will trip the s. 56 termination test but not the s. 63 severance test, because 40 per cent is under one-half but over one-quarter. Both statutory entitlements are floors anyway. See termination pay vs severance pay.

What if the negative reviews started right after I did something?

Then say so out loud, because timing shifts the burden of proof onto your employer. ESA s. 74(1) says no employer "shall intimidate, dismiss or otherwise penalize an employee or threaten to do so" for a listed reason, and s. 74(2) provides that "in any proceeding under this Act, the burden of proof that an employer did not contravene a provision set out in this section lies upon the employer." That reversal is the single most valuable thing in this article.

Section 74(1)(a) lists the protected activities. Read the whole list, because employees routinely miss the one that fits them:

  • (i) asking the employer to comply with the Act and regulations; (ii) making inquiries about your rights under the Act; (iii) filing a complaint with the Ministry; (iv) exercising or attempting to exercise a right under the Act; (v) giving information to an employment standards officer.
  • (v.1) asking about another employee's rate of pay to determine equal pay compliance under Part XII; (v.2) disclosing your own rate of pay to another employee for the same purpose. Asking a coworker what they make, for that reason, is protected.
  • (vi) testifying or participating in a proceeding under the Act; (vii) participating in proceedings about a by-law under section 4 of the Retail Business Holidays Act.
  • (viii) being or becoming eligible to take a leave, intending to take a leave, or taking a leave under Part XIV. This covers pregnancy, parental, sick, family responsibility and the other statutory leaves, and note that it protects you before you take anything.
  • (ix) asking whether a person holds a temporary help agency or recruiter licence under Part XVIII.1.

Section 74(1)(b) covers a separate situation: penalizing you because the employer is or may be required by a court order or garnishment to pay part of your wages to a third party. That limb will not apply to most performance review disputes, but it is worth knowing if a wage garnishment landed shortly before your reviews changed.

If the trigger was health and safety rather than wages, OHSA s. 50(1) is the parallel provision. No employer or person acting on behalf of an employer shall "(a) dismiss or threaten to dismiss a worker; (b) discipline or suspend or threaten to discipline or suspend a worker; (c) impose any penalty upon a worker; or (d) intimidate or coerce a worker," because the worker complied with the Act, sought its enforcement, or gave evidence in an enforcement proceeding or a Coroners Act inquest. A negative review used as discipline falls squarely inside limb (b) and arguably (c). Section 50(2) routes you to the Ontario Labour Relations Board or, if you are unionized, to arbitration under the collective agreement. Section 50(5) again places the burden of proof on the employer. Section 50(7) lets the Board substitute a lesser penalty where discipline was for cause but the contract specifies none, and s. 50(8) sends police officers under the Community Safety and Policing Act, 2019 elsewhere. See OHSA reprisal.

There is also a documentary angle worth using. OHSA s. 32.0.1(1) requires an employer to "(a) prepare a policy with respect to workplace violence; (b) prepare a policy with respect to workplace harassment; and (c) review the policies as often as is necessary, but at least annually." Section 32.0.1(2) requires those policies to be in writing and "posted at a conspicuous place in the workplace or in a readily accessible electronic format." Section 32.0.1(3) exempts workplaces with five or fewer regularly employed workers unless an inspector orders otherwise. If your employer cannot produce a current posted harassment policy, that is a compliance failure worth noting, though it is a regulatory duty and not by itself a claim for money. See workplace harassment.

If the freeze-out tracks a protected ground, Human Rights Code s. 5(1) gives every person "a right to equal treatment with respect to employment without discrimination because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, record of offences, marital status, family status or disability," and s. 5(2) gives every employee "a right to freedom from harassment in the workplace." Code s. 8 protects your right to claim and enforce Code rights "without reprisal or threat of reprisal for so doing." The test for discrimination is the three-part test in Moore v. British Columbia (Education), 2012 SCC 61: a protected characteristic, adverse treatment, and the characteristic being a factor in that treatment. One caution: Code s. 46.1(2) does not permit a civil action founded solely on a Code infringement, so Code damages ride inside another cause of action such as wrongful or constructive dismissal, or you go to the Tribunal. See workplace discrimination.

What if this is making me anxious or ill? Can I sue for that?

Not as a standalone harassment claim, and not usually as a personal injury claim. Two separate barriers apply. First, Merrifield v. Canada (Attorney General), 2019 ONCA 205 held there is no independent tort of harassment in Ontario, so "I want to sue for harassment" is not an available claim. Second, the workers' compensation bar catches most work-caused psychological injury.

On the second point, WSIA 1997 s. 28(1) provides that a worker of a Schedule 1 employer is not entitled to commence an action against that employer in respect of the worker's injury or disease, and s. 13(4) makes chronic and traumatic mental stress compensable, which pulls stress injuries inside the bar. The narrow survivor is s. 13(5): stress caused by the employer's decisions about the employment, meaning discipline, termination, and changes to work or working conditions, is excluded from benefits and so is not caught by the bar in the same way. That carve-out is precisely the terrain of a quiet firing, but it is technical and it is the reason you should not assume a civil claim for stress is open to you. See suing for PTSD from workplace harassment and stress leave.

What does travel with a dismissal claim is compensation for how the dismissal was carried out. Honda Canada Inc. v. Keays, 2008 SCC 39 and Wallace v. United Grain Growers Ltd., [1997] 3 SCR 701 address bad faith in the manner of dismissal, and Boucher v. Wal-Mart Canada Corp., 2014 ONCA 419 shows that where the treatment was egregious, aggravated and punitive damages are available. Those are damages attached to a dismissal claim, not a freestanding harassment suit. See bad faith dismissal damages.

Does any of this change if I am unionized or federally regulated?

Yes, substantially, and this is worth checking before you spend a dollar on anything else. If you are covered by a collective agreement, you generally cannot sue at all, and if you work in a federally regulated sector the Ontario ESA does not apply to you in the first place.

  • Unionized: Weber v. Ontario Hydro, [1995] 2 SCR 929 gives labour arbitration exclusive jurisdiction over disputes arising from the collective agreement, and ESA s. 99(2) closes the ESA complaint route for employees covered by an agreement. Your remedy is a grievance, and there are short grievance deadlines. Talk to your steward this week. See unionized employee rights.
  • Federally regulated (banks, airlines, telecoms, interprovincial trucking and rail, ports, federal Crown corporations): the Ontario ESA does not apply at all, and the Canada Labour Code governs. Wilson v. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., 2016 SCC 29 held that the Code's unjust dismissal scheme displaces dismissal on notice for eligible non-managerial employees, which is a stronger remedy than anything in this article, and it carries a short filing deadline. See federally regulated employee rights and CLC unjust dismissal.

Should I just quit? What happens if I get the timing wrong?

Do not quit before you get advice. This is the single most expensive mistake in quiet firing cases, and it runs in both directions. Resign too early on facts that do not meet the Potter threshold and you have simply quit, with no notice, no severance, and a harder EI application. Wait too long after a real change and you may be found to have accepted it.

Both ESA s. 56(1)(b) and s. 63(1)(b) require that the employee "resigns from his or her employment in response" to the constructive dismissal "within a reasonable period." There is no fixed number of days in the Act. What is reasonable depends on the change, how clearly it was communicated, and whether you were still negotiating or seeking advice. Continuing to work quietly under the new terms for months, without objecting, is how claims get lost.

  • Object in writing, promptly and calmly. Name the specific change, state that you do not agree to it, and ask the employer to restore the original term. That single email is often the difference between a live claim and a condoned one.
  • Keep working while you get advice, unless the workplace is genuinely unsafe. Working under protest is a recognized position, and it protects your income.
  • Understand mitigation before you decide. Evans v. Teamsters Local Union No. 31, 2008 SCC 20 holds that in some cases an employee must accept re-employment with the same employer to mitigate, which is why resigning in anger can reduce what you recover. Brake v. PJ-M2R Restaurant Inc., 2017 ONCA 402 softens this: earnings from a substantially lesser job may not be deducted from your damages. See duty to mitigate.
  • If you are being pressed to resign, do not sign anything in the meeting. See forced resignation and rescinding a heat-of-the-moment resignation.

If it is a dismissal, what is it actually worth?

Far more than the ESA minimums in most cases. The ESA sets a floor. Your contract may set something above it, and if the termination clause is unenforceable, the common law reasonable notice period revives instead: Machtinger v. HOJ Industries Ltd., [1992] 1 SCR 986. That is why the first thing a lawyer reads is your employment agreement, not your performance review.

  • Reasonable notice is assessed on the Bardal factors: length of service, age, character of employment, and availability of similar employment, from Bardal v. Globe & Mail Ltd., 1960 CanLII 294 (ON SC).
  • Termination clauses fail often. Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391 holds that one offside limb voids the termination provisions as a whole, even if the employer does not rely on that limb. Dufault v. Ignace (Township), 2024 ONSC 1029 at paras 19 to 22 examined language giving an employer broad discretion to terminate; note it is a Superior Court decision, not settled appellate authority. See is my termination clause enforceable.
  • Long-service and older employees can exceed the informal 24 month ceiling or approach it: Dawe v. The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, 2019 ONCA 512, Currie v. Nylene Canada Inc., 2022 ONCA 209, and Milwid v. IBM Canada Ltd., 2023 ONCA 702. If you were recruited away from secure employment, Dussault v. Imperial Oil Ltd, 2019 ONCA 448 is relevant to inducement.
  • Bonus and equity are usually part of the claim, not a bonus on top of it. Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26 sets the two-part test, and Paquette v. TeraGo Networks Inc., 2016 ONCA 618 confirms that an "active employment" requirement is not enough on its own to cut you off. See bonus when terminated.
  • A general two-year limitation period applies to a civil wrongful dismissal claim, and remember that under ESA s. 56(5) a layoff-based termination is deemed to occur on the first day of the layoff, which can start that clock earlier than you expect. Ontario also generally makes you choose between an ESA complaint and a court claim for the same entitlement. See limitation periods.

What should I do in the next two weeks?

Build the record before you make any decision about leaving. Quiet firing cases are won on documents and dates, and almost all of the useful documents live on a system you will lose access to the moment the employer decides to end things. Do this in order, starting today.

  1. 1.Write a dated timeline, starting from the last time things were normal. One line per event: date, what changed, who was there. Include the good reviews and the raises that came before the turn.
  2. 2.Send your own personal copy of the documents you are already entitled to have: your employment agreement and any amendments, offer letter, every performance review, the PIP, written warnings, your job description, and pay statements for the last 12 months. Take only what relates to your own employment and your own terms, nothing confidential or proprietary.
  3. 3.Track your hours and pay week by week from the first reduced week. You need this to run the s. 56(3.1) one-half test and the s. 63(2.1) one-quarter test, and you need the 12 weeks before the reduction if your hours vary.
  4. 4.Reply to the negative review in writing, factually and without heat. Correct the inaccuracies, ask what specific measurable targets apply, and ask what support will be provided. Keep it short. This is evidence, not therapy.
  5. 5.If a term has changed, object in writing now. State the change, state that you do not consent, and ask for it to be restored. Keep working while you do it.
  6. 6.If the treatment followed a protected activity, name that activity in writing too. Reprisal claims under ESA s. 74 and OHSA s. 50 are far stronger when the record shows the employer knew what you had done.
  7. 7.Do not sign a release, a severance offer, a new contract, a repayment agreement or a resignation letter without advice. See should you sign a severance offer.
  8. 8.Get advice before you resign, not after. A free review takes an hour and it is the point where these cases are usually won or lost.

⚖️If your hours, duties or pay have already changed, you may already be terminated. Under ESA s. 56(5), a layoff-based termination is deemed to have happened on the first day of the layoff, which means the clock may have started weeks before you noticed. Bring your employment agreement, your last 12 pay statements, and the review or PIP to a free, confidential severance package review. We act for employees only.

Share

Frequently asked questions

Is quiet firing illegal in Ontario?

There is no law that prohibits "quiet firing" by that name, so the phrase itself gets you nowhere. What is unlawful is the conduct underneath it: unilaterally changing a fundamental term of your job, which is constructive dismissal under ESA s. 56(1)(b); cutting your hours past the temporary layoff limits in ESA s. 56(2), which is a deemed termination under s. 56(1)(c); or penalizing you for a protected activity, which is reprisal under ESA s. 74(1), OHSA s. 50(1) or Human Rights Code s. 8. Frame your situation as one of those and you have a claim. Frame it as "my manager is freezing me out" and you may not.

Can my employer put me on a PIP purely to push me out?

An employer can put you on a performance improvement plan, and a PIP on its own is not a dismissal. But a PIP built on targets nobody else is held to, imposed after your best accounts were reassigned, with no support and an impossible deadline, is evidence for the second branch of Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10: a course of conduct showing the employer no longer intends to be bound by the contract. Respond in writing, factually, ask for the specific measurable targets and the support being offered, and keep every version of the plan. If the PIP arrived shortly after you asserted an ESA right, took a leave under Part XIV or raised a safety issue, ESA s. 74(2) and OHSA s. 50(5) put the burden on the employer to prove that was not the reason.

How long do I have to resign before I lose the constructive dismissal claim?

The ESA does not give a number. Both s. 56(1)(b) and s. 63(1)(b) require the employee to resign "in response to" the constructive dismissal "within a reasonable period," and what is reasonable depends on how clear the change was, whether you objected, and whether you were getting advice or negotiating. Continuing to work under the new terms for months without saying anything is how employees lose these claims to condonation. The protective move is to object in writing promptly, say clearly that you do not consent to the change, and keep working while you get advice, which is one of the three options recognized in Wronko v. Western Inventory Service Ltd., 2008 ONCA 327.

If I resign because of quiet firing, can I still get EI?

Possibly, but do not treat it as automatic. EI is a federal program administered by Service Canada, and quitting voluntarily generally disqualifies you unless you had just cause under the federal rules. Circumstances that support a constructive dismissal claim, such as a significant unilateral pay cut or removal of duties, can also support a just cause finding for EI, but Service Canada makes that decision independently of any employment law claim you bring, and it will want documentation. This is one more reason to object in writing before you resign: the paper trail serves both purposes. See our page on quitting versus being fired and how it affects EI and severance.

About the Author
Daniel Carter

Daniel Carter

Legal Writer, Mirza Law

Daniel Carter is a legal writer at Mirza Law in Toronto. He writes about layoffs, employment contracts, and the steps to take before you sign anything from your employer.

See all articles

Whenever you're ready, we're here.

Prefer to call?(289) 272-2412

Let's Connect