Executive CompensationEquityRSUsStock OptionsEmployment Standards ActStatutory NoticeSeverance

Does the ESA Protect My Equity Compensation During the Statutory Notice Period?

Section 60 (1) (a) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 says an employer "shall not reduce the employee's wage rate or alter any other term or condition of employment" during the statutory notice period, and s. 61 (1) (a) carries that into the lump sum an employer pays when it walks you out. Your vesting schedule is a term or condition of employment. Here is the full statutory walk-through for an executive with RSUs, options, a bonus and a pension on the table.

Written By: Daniel Carter|Reviewed By: Amir Mirza
Updated: August 2026
Close-up of a focused eye behind thick black-framed glasses with screen light reflected in the lens.

Key takeaways

  • Section 60 (1) (a) is the argument. During the statutory notice period the employer "shall not reduce the employee's wage rate or alter any other term or condition of employment", and your grant agreement, your vesting dates and your plan participation are terms and conditions of employment.
  • Section 61 (1) (a) means being walked out changes nothing. Pay in lieu must be "a lump sum equal to the amount the employee would have been entitled to receive under section 60 had notice been given", so the measure is the counterfactual, not the day they took your laptop.
  • Section 5 (1) makes offending wording void, not merely unfair. Your signature, your title and your independent legal advice do not save it (Rahman v. Cannon Design Architecture Inc., 2022 ONCA 451).
  • Whether equity is "wages" under s. 1 has not been decided, and the s. 60 (1) (a) argument does not depend on it. Do not let an employer collapse the two questions into one.
  • The statutory window is at most 8 weeks, and that is not the point. A void clause revives the common law right to reasonable notice (Machtinger v. HOJ Industries Ltd., [1992] 1 SCR 986), and that is where an executive package is actually won or lost.
In this article

✅Quick answer. Partly, and the part it protects is the part employers assume they can take. Section 60 (1) (a) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 says that during the statutory notice period the employer "shall not reduce the employee's wage rate or alter any other term or condition of employment", and s. 61 (1) (a) requires pay in lieu to equal what s. 60 would have given you. Your vesting schedule is a term or condition of employment, so a clause cancelling unvested equity on your last day is void for that window under s. 5 (1). Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., 2026 ONCA 572, a recent decision released in August 2026, adopts that reading. The catch is that the statutory window is short, at most 8 weeks, so the ESA is your floor and your lever rather than your whole claim.

If you are a senior manager, a vice president or an executive, this is not an academic question. Base salary is usually the smallest moving part of your package. The unvested RSUs, the performance share units, the options, the deferred bonus, the pension accrual and the benefits are where the money sits, and the employer's letter almost always prices the salary and writes off everything else in a single sentence about unvested awards being cancelled on the termination date.

There are two separate legal routes at your disposal, and they are constantly confused. One is the Employment Standards Act, 2000, which sets a statutory floor measured in weeks and makes offending contract wording void. The other is your common law right to reasonable notice, measured in months, which carries the whole package. The statutory route is narrower and stronger. The common law route is wider and softer. You want both, in that order.

What does the ESA actually guarantee during the statutory notice period?

Three things, set out in s. 60 (1). Your wage rate cannot be cut and no other term or condition of employment can be altered. You must be paid weekly wages that are never less than your regular wages for a regular work week. And your benefit plan contributions must continue to the end of the notice period. The first of those three is the one executives never hear about.

  • Clause 60 (1) (a). The employer "shall not reduce the employee's wage rate or alter any other term or condition of employment". That is two prohibitions, not one. The first is about your rate of pay. The second is about everything else your employment consists of, and it is deliberately open ended.
  • Clause 60 (1) (b). The employer "shall in each week pay the employee the wages the employee is entitled to receive, which in no case shall be less than his or her regular wages for a regular work week". Note the structure: this is a floor, not a ceiling, and it does not cut down what clause (a) protects.
  • Clause 60 (1) (c). The employer "shall continue to make whatever benefit plan contributions would be required to be made in order to maintain the employee's benefits under the plan until the end of the notice period". Your group life, LTD, health and dental coverage cannot be cut off on your last day.
  • Subsection 60 (2). If you have no regular work week, or you are "paid on a basis other than time", the weekly figure under clause (b) is "the average amount of regular wages earned by the employee per week for the weeks in which the employee worked in the period of 12 weeks immediately preceding the day on which notice was given". Executives on salary plus heavy variable pay should read that limb twice.
  • Subsection 60 (3). If the employer fails to make the benefit plan contributions required by clause (c), "an amount equal to the amount the employer should have contributed shall be deemed to be unpaid wages for the purpose of section 103", which is the Act's enforcement machinery.
  • Subsection 60 (4). "Nothing in subsection (3) precludes the employee from an entitlement that he or she may have under a benefit plan." The statutory remedy sits on top of your rights under the plan itself; it does not replace them.

How does section 60 (1) (a) reach my unvested RSUs and options?

Through the second half of the clause. Clause 60 (1) (a) does not stop at your wage rate. It forbids the employer to "alter any other term or condition of employment". Your participation in the equity plan, the grants already made to you and the vesting dates attached to those grants are terms and conditions of your employment. Cancelling them on your last day alters them.

Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., 2026 ONCA 572, a recent decision, adopted exactly that reasoning: clauses that end vesting on termination are void, because s. 60 (1) (a), read into s. 61 (1) (a), forbids an employer to alter any term or condition of employment during the statutory notice period. The employee recovered restricted share units worth roughly US$4.7 million over a 10 month notice period, and the court gave no discount for the fact that the agreement had been negotiated by counsel. It was released in August 2026 and its outer limits have not been tested, so treat it as a strong argument rather than a closed question.

There is a second statutory hook that most executives never hear about. Section 62 (1) says that where an employer terminates without giving part or all of the required notice, the employees "shall be deemed to have been actively employed during the period for which there should have been notice for the purposes of any benefit plan under which entitlement to benefits might be lost or affected if the employees cease to be actively employed". Being deemed actively employed is the precise condition your plan says you failed. Whether a share unit plan is a "benefit plan", defined in s. 1 as "a benefit plan provided for an employee by or through his or her employer", has not been settled by an Ontario appellate decision, so run this as an alternative argument rather than the main one.

Section 62 (2) and (3) complete that picture. A failure to make the contributions required by clause 61 (1) (b) is "deemed to be unpaid wages for the purpose of section 103", and nothing in that subsection "precludes the employee from an entitlement he or she may have under a benefit plan". Subsection 62 (1) is the operative limb for equity; subsections (2) and (3) are about the money and the parallel plan remedy.

I was walked out the same day. Does section 61 change the answer?

No, and that is the architecture of the whole Part. Section 61 lets an employer skip notice, but only by paying what notice would have delivered. Clause 61 (1) (a) requires "termination pay in a lump sum equal to the amount the employee would have been entitled to receive under section 60 had notice been given in accordance with that section". The reference is to section 60 as a whole.

  • Clause 61 (1) (a). The measure is a counterfactual: what would you have received had you worked out the notice period? If a tranche would have vested on 15 March and your statutory notice period ran to 26 April, the honest answer includes that tranche. The clause does not say "equal to the wages under clause 60 (1) (b)"; it says equal to the amount you would have received under section 60.
  • Clause 61 (1) (b). The employer "continues to make whatever benefit plan contributions would be required to be made in order to maintain the benefits to which the employee would have been entitled had he or she continued to be employed during the period of notice". Same counterfactual, applied to the plans.
  • Subsection 61 (1.1). Where you have no regular work week or are "paid on a basis other than time", the calculation uses "the 12-week period immediately preceding the day of termination" rather than the 12 weeks before notice was given, as s. 60 (2) would have it. For an executive with lumpy variable pay, moving the measuring window can move the number, so check which one applies to you.
  • Subsection 61 (2). This limb engages only in a group termination: an employer terminating under s. 61 that "would otherwise be required to provide notices of termination under section 58 shall comply with clause 58 (2) (a)". If you were let go on your own, it does not apply to you at all.

I signed the plan documents. Can I still say the forfeiture clause is void?

Yes. Section 5 (1) says "no employer or agent of an employer and no employee or agent of an employee shall contract out of or waive an employment standard and any such contracting out or waiver is void". Your signature is not a defence to that section; your signature is the thing the section is aimed at. There is exactly one escape, in s. 5 (2).

Subsection 5 (2) is the greater benefit rule: "If one or more provisions in an employment contract or in another Act that directly relate to the same subject matter as an employment standard provide a greater benefit to an employee than the employment standard, the provision or provisions in the contract or Act apply and the employment standard does not apply." It has two cumulative requirements. The contract provision must relate directly to the same subject matter, and it must give you more. A clause cancelling unvested awards on the termination date fails the second requirement on its face. It is not a greater benefit; it is a smaller one, so the employment standard continues to apply and the clause is void to the extent it conflicts.

Executives are routinely told that because they are sophisticated and had their own counsel, the wording will be held to them. Rahman v. Cannon Design Architecture Inc., 2022 ONCA 451 says the opposite: sophistication and independent legal advice do not save a termination clause that offends the ESA. The same decision treated a parent company that directed, paid and pooled the executive as a common employer, which matters when your grants come from a United States parent and your pay comes from the Canadian subsidiary. See also when a termination clause is unenforceable.

Is my equity "wages" under the ESA, and does the answer matter?

It has not been decided, and for the s. 60 (1) (a) argument it does not need to be. Clause (a) protects terms and conditions of employment, not just wages. The wages question bites elsewhere: in the weekly payment obligation in clause 60 (1) (b), in the severance pay calculation under s. 65, and in enforcement of unpaid wages. Walk the definition in s. 1 before you take a position.

  • Inclusion (a): "monetary remuneration payable by an employer to an employee under the terms of an employment contract, oral or written, express or implied". Units settled in cash look like monetary remuneration. Units settled in shares do not obviously fit, and that is the live argument.
  • Inclusion (b): "any payment required to be made by an employer to an employee under this Act". Termination pay itself lands here, which is why unpaid termination pay is recoverable as wages.
  • Inclusion (c): "any allowances for room or board under an employment contract or prescribed allowances". Nothing to do with equity, and it will not arise in an executive file unless you had a housing allowance.
  • Exclusion (d): tips or other gratuities. Never relevant to an equity claim.
  • Exclusion (e): "any sums paid as gifts or bonuses that are dependent on the discretion of the employer and that are not related to hours, production or efficiency". This is the exclusion the employer will reach for. It has two cumulative conditions. The award must be discretionary AND unrelated to hours, production or efficiency. A grant sized by a performance formula, or a PSU with a measurable payout multiplier, is not comfortably inside it.
  • Exclusion (f): expenses and travelling allowances. Not relevant.
  • Exclusion (g): "subject to subsections 60 (3) or 62 (2), employer contributions to a benefit plan and payments to which an employee is entitled from a benefit plan". Note the tension this creates: characterising your equity plan as a benefit plan takes it out of "wages", but it also pulls in the deemed active employment rule in s. 62 (1). The two arguments point in opposite directions and you should know which one you are running.

The practical instruction is simple. Build the claim on s. 60 (1) (a), which does not turn on the characterisation at all. Keep the wages characterisation as a secondary argument, and do not accept an employer's assertion that the point is settled, because it is not. See also bonus when terminated and discretionary bonus during the notice period.

How long is my statutory notice period, and how is severance pay calculated?

For most executives, 8 weeks. Section 57 sets notice by completed service and stops at clause (h). Severance pay is a separate entitlement, calculated under s. 65 on regular wages, and capped at 26 weeks. Both matter here, because the length of the window decides how many vesting dates fall inside it.

  • Clause 57 (a): at least one week, if your period of employment is less than one year.
  • Clause 57 (b): at least two weeks, one year or more and fewer than three years.
  • Clause 57 (c): at least three weeks, three years or more and fewer than four years.
  • Clause 57 (d): at least four weeks, four years or more and fewer than five years.
  • Clause 57 (e): at least five weeks, five years or more and fewer than six years.
  • Clause 57 (f): at least six weeks, six years or more and fewer than seven years.
  • Clause 57 (g): at least seven weeks, seven years or more and fewer than eight years.
  • Clause 57 (h): at least eight weeks, eight years or more. There is nothing above this in s. 57, so a 25 year executive and a 9 year executive get the same statutory notice.

The definition of "statutory notice period" in s. 1 has two limbs, and the second one is a trap. Limb (a) is "the period of notice of termination required to be given by an employer under Part XV". Limb (b) applies "where the employer provides a greater amount of notice than is required under Part XV", and in that case only "that part of the notice period ending with the termination date specified in the notice which equals the period of notice required under Part XV" counts. If you are handed 6 months of working notice, the s. 60 protections attach to the final 8 weeks of it, not to the whole 6 months. A tranche vesting in month two of a long working notice is outside the statutory shelter and has to be won on common law grounds instead.

Section 60 (1) applies to a notice period "under section 57 or 58". Section 58 is the provision that governs notice where a group of employees is terminated, and s. 61 (2) cross refers to it. If you went out in a larger group, your statutory notice period may be set by that section instead, which changes the size of the window in which s. 60 (1) (a) operates. See mass terminations.

Severance pay is different money, on a different formula. Eligibility is governed by s. 64 (1); the calculation is in s. 65, and every subsection of it matters to a long service executive.

  • Subsection 65 (1): your "regular wages for a regular work week" multiplied by the sum of (a) completed years of employment and (b) completed months not counted in (a), divided by 12.
  • Subsection 65 (2): all time in the employer's employ counts, "whether or not continuous and whether or not active", both for eligibility and for the calculation.
  • Subsection 65 (2.1): the exception. An employee receiving an actuarially unreduced pension benefit, severed on or after November 6, 2009, does not count service for which service credits went into that pension. Long service executives with a defined benefit pension should check this before assuming a large severance figure.
  • Subsection 65 (3): a narrow rule for a severance under clause 63 (1) (e), excluding the period between the employee's resignation notice and the date the employer's notice would have taken effect. It will not arise on an ordinary without cause termination.
  • Subsection 65 (4): where the employer fails to give the notice required by s. 57 or 58, severance is calculated "as if the employee continued to be employed for a period equal to the period of notice that should have been given and was not". A pay in lieu termination can therefore push you over a completed month or a completed year.
  • Subsection 65 (5): the cap. Severance pay "shall not exceed an amount equal to the employee's regular wages for a regular work week for 26 weeks".
  • Subsection 65 (6): where there is no regular work week or you are paid on a basis other than time, use the 12 week average, measured from (a) the date employment was severed, or (b) where severance arises under clause 63 (1) (c) or (d), the date the lay off began. Limb (b) is a lay off rule and will not apply if you were terminated outright.
  • Subsection 65 (7): severance "is in addition to any other amount to which an employee is entitled under this Act or his or her employment contract", subject only to subsection (8).
  • Subsection 65 (8): only three set offs are permitted. Supplementary unemployment benefits received after severance and before severance pay becomes payable; an amount paid for loss of employment under a contractual provision "if it is based upon length of employment, length of service or seniority"; and severance pay previously paid under the Act, a predecessor Act, or such a contractual provision. Nothing else may be deducted. Accelerated vesting of equity is not on that list, so an employer that says "we vested your March tranche, that covers your severance" is deducting something the statute does not permit it to deduct.

How does the ESA floor compare with my common law claim?

The ESA gives you weeks; the common law gives you months. The ESA freezes the terms of your employment for a window that maxes out at 8 weeks and voids clauses that offend it. A common law reasonable notice claim can run to 24 months and carries the whole package, subject to your duty to mitigate. Here is how each component is treated on both tracks.

Package componentDuring the statutory notice periodOver a common law reasonable notice period
Base salaryMust be paid weekly at no less than regular wages for a regular work week (s. 60 (1) (b)); the rate cannot be reduced (s. 60 (1) (a))Payable for the whole notice period, less earnings in mitigation
Annual bonusContested. It depends on whether the bonus is "wages" under s. 1, and exclusion (e) removes truly discretionary bonuses unrelated to hours, production or efficiencyPresumptively included under the two part test in Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26; active employment wording usually fails (Paquette v. TeraGo Networks Inc., 2016 ONCA 618)
RSUs and PSUs vesting in the windowVesting cannot be altered: s. 60 (1) (a), applied in Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., 2026 ONCA 572, a recent decisionTranches that would have vested during the notice period are presumptively recoverable (O'Reilly v. IMAX Corporation, 2019 ONCA 991), valued at each vest date
Stock optionsSame analysis: the vesting date and the exercise window are both terms of employmentDepends on wording. Unambiguous wording ending options when services cease has been enforced (Kieran v. Ingram Micro Inc., 2004 CanLII 4852 (ON CA))
Deferred compensation and notional share awardsMay be caught by ss. 60 (1) (c), 61 (1) (b) and 62 (1) if the arrangement is a benefit planRecoverable even where the vesting date falls after the notice period ends, on the wording in Bain v. UBS Securities Canada Inc., 2018 ONCA 190
Pension and retirement contributionsContributions must continue (s. 60 (1) (c)) or be paid (s. 61 (1) (b)); unpaid amounts are deemed unpaid wages (ss. 60 (3), 62 (2))Accrual over the notice period is recoverable (Taggart v. Canada Life Assurance Company, 2006 CanLII 53345 (ON CA))
Group benefits and LTD coverageContributions continue to the end of the notice period (s. 60 (1) (c)) and you are deemed actively employed for plan purposes (s. 62 (1))Valued at replacement cost without proof of actual loss (Singer v. Nordstrong Equipment Limited, 2018 ONCA 364); cancelling disability coverage can make the employer liable for the benefits themselves (Egan v. Alcatel Canada Inc., 2006 CanLII 108 (ON CA))
Shares you bought with your own moneyLikely outside the analysis; this is a shareholding, not an employment termTreated as shareholder rights, with the buy back and valuation running from the termination date (Mikelsteins v. Morrison Hershfield Limited, 2021 ONCA 155)
Severance payCalculated on regular wages for a regular work week (s. 65 (1)), capped at 26 weeks (s. 65 (5)), with only the three set offs in s. 65 (8)Credited against common law damages rather than added to them

What does this look like in actual numbers?

It usually means the offer is worth a fraction of the claim, and the ESA floor alone is worth roughly double the offer. Take a vice president, age 52, 9 years of service, terminated on 1 March. Base salary $300,000 (about $5,769 a week). Target bonus $150,000, paid each March for the prior year. Employer retirement contributions $18,000 a year. Benefits replacement cost about $800 a month.

Her equity is 24,000 unvested units, vesting 2,000 per quarter on 15 March, 15 June, 15 September and 15 December, with an illustrative share price of $50, so $100,000 a tranche. Her statutory notice period is 8 weeks under clause 57 (h), running from 1 March to 26 April, so the 15 March tranche falls inside it. Assume she is eligible for severance pay under s. 64 (1). Because she is paid in lieu, s. 65 (4) adds the notice that was not given, so her service for the severance calculation is 9 years plus one completed month: 9 + 1/12 = 9.083 weeks of regular wages. Assume a reasonable notice period of 20 months at common law, which would capture seven quarterly tranches.

ComponentIn the employer's offerESA floor (8 week statutory notice period)Common law claim (20 months, illustrative)
Base salary at $5,769 a week17 weeks of base, about $98,1008 weeks of termination pay, about $46,20020 months, $500,000
Severance pay (s. 65)Rolled into the 17 weeks9.083 weeks of regular wages, about $52,400Credited against the damages, not added to them
Annual bonus ($150,000 target)Nil, on the basis that she is not actively employed on the payout dateContested; turns on whether the bonus is "wages" under s. 1Prior year plus 20 months pro rata, about $400,000
RSUs (2,000 units a quarter at $50)Nil, all unvested units cancelled on the termination dateThe 15 March tranche sits inside the window: $100,0007 tranches, about $700,000 at a flat illustrative $50
Employer retirement contributionsNil8 weeks of contributions, about $2,80020 months, $30,000
Group benefits and LTD8 weeks of coverageContributions to the end of the notice period, about $1,50020 months at replacement cost, about $16,000
TotalAbout $98,000About $203,000About $1,646,000 before mitigation earnings

Two things fall out of that table. First, the ESA floor by itself is worth roughly twice the offer, and it is not negotiable, because s. 5 (1) makes a waiver void. Second, the gap between the statutory floor and the common law claim is about $1.4 million, and almost all of it is bonus and equity. Real share prices move, so build the schedule tranche by tranche at the price on each vest date rather than applying one number to everything. See also how RSU tranches are valued.

Which plan wordings have actually worked, and which have failed?

Employers reuse a short list of formulas, and Ontario appellate courts have looked at most of them. The pattern is consistent: language keyed to active employment or to the fact of termination has repeatedly failed, while language that is genuinely unambiguous, or that the employee expressly acknowledged, has sometimes been enforced at common law.

Wording in the plan or agreementWhat has happened to it
"You must be actively employed on the vesting date"Active employment wording does not by itself remove damages for the notice period (Paquette v. TeraGo Networks Inc., 2016 ONCA 618)
"In good standing at the time bonuses are payable"Treated as the same thing as actively employed, and it does not bar damages; the employee received a pro rata share for the year worked and for the notice period even though the payout date fell after the notice period ended (Andros v. Colliers Macaulay Nicolls Inc., 2019 ONCA 679)
"No bonus if terminated prior to payout"An active employment clause. Incentive plans making up around 60 per cent of pay were still recoverable, and "terminated" was read as lawfully terminated (Lin v. Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan, 2016 ONCA 619)
"Unvested units are cancelled on the termination date, whether or not the termination is lawful"Void for the statutory notice period, because it alters a term or condition of employment contrary to s. 60 (1) (a) (Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., 2026 ONCA 572, a recent decision)
"Options terminate on the date the employee ceases to provide services, regardless of any pay in lieu"Enforced on that wording as a matter of contract, with no option damages awarded (Kieran v. Ingram Micro Inc., 2004 CanLII 4852 (ON CA)); the ESA argument was not made in that case
A deferred bonus in notional shares vesting after the notice period ends, with a plan disclaimerRecoverable; the wording did not unambiguously exclude the deferred portion earned during the notice period (Bain v. UBS Securities Canada Inc., 2018 ONCA 190)
A click through acknowledgement that you read and accepted harsh forfeiture termsEnforced. The Court of Appeal reversed the trial decision at 2020 ONSC 4286 and held the employee to his acknowledgement (Battiston v. Microsoft Canada Inc., 2021 ONCA 727)
A share buy back triggered on the day of dismissalEnforced on that agreement's wording, on the basis that the employee ceased to be an employee on the day of dismissal (Love v. Acuity Investment Management Inc., 2011 ONCA 130)
Shares purchased with the employee's own funds under a shareholders' agreementShareholder rights, not employment compensation; the valuation date ran from termination (Mikelsteins v. Morrison Hershfield Limited, 2021 ONCA 155)
An amendment to the incentive plan you never signedForfeiture amendments the employees refused to sign never became part of the contract (Lin v. Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan, 2016 ONCA 619)
A just cause clause anywhere in the termination scheme that denies all notice and payVoid, and it takes the rest of the termination provisions with it (Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, where leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was dismissed; applied to an executive in Rahman v. Cannon Design Architecture Inc., 2022 ONCA 451)

If your plan was amended after you were granted your awards and you never signed anything, flag it early. See a bonus plan amendment you never signed.

What should I be reading in my own grant agreement?

Nine things, and most of them are not in the employment agreement at all. They are in the plan document, the grant notice and the vesting schedule, which are usually three separate files in three separate systems. Pull all of them before you respond to anything, because the arithmetic of your claim lives there.

What to findWhat to look forWhat it means for you
The vesting scheduleExact calendar vest dates and the number of units in each tranche, grant by grantThis is the arithmetic. Tranches inside the statutory notice period are the strongest claim you have; tranches inside a common law notice period are the largest
The definition of termination datePhrases like "ceases to be actively employed" or "without regard to any period of notice, whether contractual, statutory or at common law"That is the clause held void for the statutory notice period in Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., 2026 ONCA 572, a recent decision, and the clause that has repeatedly failed at common law
Good leaver or qualifying termination definitionsWhether a without cause termination is a good leaver event, and whether retirement eligibility or a rule of 65 or 70 changes the treatmentMany plans give full or pro rata vesting to a good leaver. If you are near a retirement threshold, this can be the single largest number in the file
Change of control languageWhether acceleration is single trigger (on the deal) or double trigger (deal plus termination), and how "good reason" is definedIf you were terminated near a transaction, the acceleration clause may already do the work without any argument
Clawback and recoupmentWhat triggers a recovery of amounts already paid, and whether it reaches vested and settled awardsThis is the employer's counterweight. Read it before you take a position on cause or on competing after you leave
The amendment powerWhether the employer can change plan terms unilaterally, and whether you ever actually agreedAn amendment you never accepted may never have become part of your contract (Lin v. Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan, 2016 ONCA 619)
Who granted the unitsWhether the grantor is a foreign parent while your employer of record is the Canadian subsidiaryA parent that directs, pays and pools the executive can be a common employer (Rahman v. Cannon Design Architecture Inc., 2022 ONCA 451)
Governing law and the conflicts clauseA foreign choice of law, and any clause saying the plan prevails over your employment agreementOntario employment standards are not a matter of contractual choice for an employee working in Ontario, and s. 5 (1) voids any waiver of them. Raise it before you negotiate
The release in the offerWhether it releases claims under the equity plan and the pension, and whether it extends to the parent and the LTD carrierA release is close to impossible to unwind once signed. See should I sign the release

When does none of this apply to me?

In four situations. You are federally regulated, so the ESA does not apply at all. You are unionized, so your dispute belongs to arbitration. Your termination falls inside one of the exemptions in O. Reg. 288/01, so there is no statutory notice period for s. 60 to protect. Or your equity is really a shareholding you bought with your own money.

If your employer is a bank, an airline, a railway, an interprovincial trucking company, a telecommunications or broadcasting business or another federal work or undertaking, the Employment Standards Act, 2000 does not apply to you and none of the sections above are available. The Canada Labour Code applies instead, with a different notice regime and an unjust dismissal process that can displace dismissal on notice (Wilson v. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., 2016 SCC 29), although managers are generally excluded from that process. See federally regulated employees.

If you are covered by a collective agreement, a dispute arising from that agreement belongs to a labour arbitrator with exclusive jurisdiction (Weber v. Ontario Hydro, [1995] 2 SCR 929), and the ESA complaint route is closed to you as well. Your remedy runs through your union and the grievance procedure. See unionized employees.

The exemptions in s. 2 (1) of O. Reg. 288/01 remove notice and termination pay entirely for twelve categories, and with no statutory notice period there is nothing for s. 60 (1) (a) to protect. Here is the full list and why most of them will not touch a senior manager terminated without cause.

  • Paragraph 1, definite term or specific task. Subject to s. 2 (2), which takes the exemption away if (a) the employment terminates before the term expires or the task is completed, (b) the term expires or the task is unfinished more than 12 months after employment commenced, or (c) the employment continues for three months or more after expiry. Most executive fixed term arrangements fail at least one of those, so the exemption usually collapses.
  • Paragraph 2, temporary lay off, and paragraph 7, failing to return within a reasonable time after being recalled. Neither applies to an outright termination.
  • Paragraph 3, wilful misconduct, disobedience or wilful neglect of duty "that is not trivial and has not been condoned by the employer". This is the one employers reach for, and the standard is higher than common law just cause. Cause is assessed contextually and proportionately (McKinley v. BC Tel, 2001 SCC 38), and an employee can lose at common law and still be owed ESA entitlements (Render v. ThyssenKrupp Elevator (Canada) Limited, 2022 ONCA 310). Poor performance, a restructuring dressed up as cause, or a single lapse will rarely meet it.
  • Paragraph 4, frustration, subject to s. 2 (3), which removes the exemption where the frustration results from an illness or injury suffered by the employee, and s. 2 (4), which is about licence decisions for temporary help agencies and recruiters. If you were terminated during a long illness, s. 2 (3) is your provision. See frustration of contract.
  • Paragraph 5, refusing an offer of reasonable alternative employment with the employer, and paragraph 6, refusing alternative employment made available through a seniority system. Paragraph 5 can arise if you turned down a role the employer offered; paragraph 6 assumes a seniority system, which non union executives do not have.
  • Paragraphs 8 to 12. Termination during or as a result of a strike or lock out; construction employees; paragraph 10, revoked; retirement at the employer's established retirement age, and only where that would not contravene the Human Rights Code; and shipbuilding employees, which requires all three of conditions (i), (ii) and (iii) in paragraph 12. None of these arise in an ordinary executive termination.

If the ESA only buys me 8 weeks, why does any of this matter?

Because a clause that offends the ESA is void, not merely trimmed, and a void termination scheme revives your common law right to reasonable notice. The 8 week point is the lever. The 18 or 24 month claim is the load it lifts. That is the single most valuable thing an executive can take away from the statute.

Where a termination clause is invalid, the common law presumption of reasonable notice comes back (Machtinger v. HOJ Industries Ltd., [1992] 1 SCR 986). One offside limb voids the termination provisions as a whole, so a just cause clause the employer never even used can bring down the without cause clause beside it (Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, where leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was dismissed). In Dufault v. Ignace (Township), 2024 ONSC 1029 the court reasoned at paragraphs 19 to 22 about a clause allowing termination at the employer's sole discretion; that reasoning has not been settled at the appellate level, so raise it as one argument among several rather than as a decided point.

The length of the notice period is then set by the familiar factors of character of employment, length of service, age and availability of similar employment (Bardal v. Globe & Mail Ltd., 1960 CanLII 294 (ON SC)). Executives do well on those factors and equity participation itself lengthens the period, because it makes comparable employment harder to find, so short service must not be over weighted (Love v. Acuity Investment Management Inc., 2011 ONCA 130, where a senior vice president with 2.5 years received 9 months). Reported outcomes have included 15 months for an eight year head of global funds where a cause allegation clouded re-employment (Lin v. Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan, 2016 ONCA 619), 17 months for a divisional president (Singer v. Nordstrong Equipment Limited, 2018 ONCA 364), 18 months for a managing director (Bain v. UBS Securities Canada Inc., 2018 ONCA 190), and 24 months for an older long service employee (Dawe v. The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, 2019 ONCA 512). Above 24 months requires exceptional circumstances (Lowndes v. Summit Ford Sales Ltd., 2006 CanLII 14 (ON CA)). If you were recruited away from a secure job, inducement lengthens the period as well (Egan v. Alcatel Canada Inc., 2006 CanLII 108 (ON CA)).

Two qualifications. You must look for comparable work, and earnings from new employment during the notice period are generally deducted (Evans v. Teamsters Local Union No. 31, 2008 SCC 20), although income from a substantially lesser job may not be (Brake v. PJ-M2R Restaurant Inc., 2017 ONCA 402). And if your role changed fundamentally since you signed, an old contract may no longer govern at all (Celestini v. Shoplogix Inc., 2023 ONCA 131). See the 24 month cap for executives and executive severance caps.

What should I do before I respond to the offer?

Work in this order. Price the package first, then test the clauses, then negotiate. Almost every expensive mistake in an executive file happens because the reader answered the deadline in the letter instead of the arithmetic in the plan documents.

  1. 1.Do not sign the release and do not accept the deadline as fixed. A deadline in a without prejudice letter is a negotiating device, not a limitation period.
  2. 2.Download every grant notice, plan document and vesting statement from the equity portal today, before your access is cut off. Screenshot the vesting schedule and the unvested balance with the date visible.
  3. 3.Build a tranche by tranche schedule: grant date, vest date, number of units, and the share price on each vest date. Mark which tranches fall inside your statutory notice period under s. 57 and which fall inside a realistic common law notice period.
  4. 4.Calculate your ESA floor separately: termination pay under ss. 57 and 61, severance under s. 65 including the s. 65 (4) credit for notice not given, and benefit and pension contributions under ss. 60 (1) (c) and 61 (1) (b). That number is not negotiable, so it is your starting line, not your finish line.
  5. 5.Have the termination clause in your employment agreement tested first. If it fails, the common law claim and the whole equity and bonus component open up. See signs a termination clause is unenforceable.
  6. 6.Check whether your benefits, LTD and life coverage have already been cut off. Coverage lapsing during the statutory notice period is a breach of clause 60 (1) (c) on its own. See benefits after termination.
  7. 7.Start a mitigation file the same week: applications, recruiters, interviews, dates, outcomes. Record the equity component of any new offer, because it affects both mitigation and your negotiating position. See the duty to mitigate.
  8. 8.Get tax advice on how a settlement will be characterised before you agree to a structure, because equity, retiring allowances and salary continuance are taxed differently. See is severance taxable.
  9. 9.Have the whole package reviewed before you reply. A severance package review should price the equity and the pension, not just count the weeks.

Which documents should I gather, and what should I ask?

Bring everything that defines a component of your pay, not just the termination letter. In an executive file the termination letter is usually the least informative document in the folder, because the value is buried in plan documents that the employer did not attach to the offer.

  • The offer of employment and every amending letter, promotion letter and retention agreement, in the order you signed them.
  • The equity plan document, every grant notice or award agreement, and the vesting schedule with current unvested balances.
  • Bonus and incentive plan documents for the last three years, plus the actual payout statements, so target and actual can be compared.
  • Pension plan booklet or statement, and the retirement savings contribution history.
  • Benefits booklet, including the long term disability and life insurance certificates, and confirmation of the date coverage ends.
  • The termination letter, the offer, the draft release and any severance calculation the employer provided.
  • Your last twelve weeks of pay records, which is the window ss. 60 (2) and 61 (1.1) use for variable pay.
  • Performance reviews, any performance improvement plan, and anything the employer has said about cause.
  • Restrictive covenants, clawback policies and any share ownership guideline you were subject to.
  • Exactly which date is my termination date, and what is my statutory notice period under s. 57?
  • Which tranches vest inside that window, and what is each one worth?
  • Has the employer treated my unvested equity as cancelled on the termination date, and does that clause survive s. 60 (1) (a) and s. 5 (1)?
  • Is my termination clause enforceable, and if not, what does a reasonable notice period look like for someone at my level and service?
  • Was vacation pay calculated on my bonus as well as my salary? A bonus tied to production can attract vacation pay (Bain v. UBS Securities Canada Inc., 2018 ONCA 190).
  • Is the severance calculation right, including the s. 65 (4) credit for notice not given, and has the employer deducted anything not permitted by s. 65 (8)?
  • Am I a good leaver under the plan, and am I close to any retirement or vesting threshold that changes the treatment?
  • What exactly does the release give up, and does it reach my pension, my equity and my disability coverage?

The reason to do this before you respond is simple. The statutory arguments are the ones that cannot be waived, the equity numbers are the ones the employer has not priced, and both disappear the moment you sign. See also what an executive is owed on termination and your rights under the ESA.

This article is general information about Ontario law. It is not legal advice about your situation.

Share

Frequently asked questions

My plan says unvested units are cancelled on my termination date regardless of any notice period. Is that enforceable?

Not for the statutory notice period. Section 60 (1) (a) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 says the employer "shall not reduce the employee's wage rate or alter any other term or condition of employment" during that period, s. 61 (1) (a) requires pay in lieu to equal what s. 60 would have delivered, and s. 5 (1) makes any contracting out void. Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., 2026 ONCA 572, a recent decision released in August 2026, held that clauses ending vesting on termination are void on exactly that reasoning. Beyond the statutory window the analysis shifts to your common law claim, where such wording has often failed but has occasionally been enforced.

The employer accelerated one RSU tranche and says that covers my ESA entitlements. Can it do that?

No, not as a deduction from severance pay. Subsection 65 (8) permits only three set offs: supplementary unemployment benefits received before severance pay becomes payable, an amount paid for loss of employment under a contractual provision "if it is based upon length of employment, length of service or seniority", and severance pay previously paid under the Act or such a provision. A vesting acceleration is none of those. Separately, s. 65 (7) says severance pay is in addition to any other amount you are entitled to under the Act or your contract.

Does the ESA protect my bonus during the statutory notice period as well?

It depends on characterisation, and that is genuinely unresolved. Clause 60 (1) (b) requires payment of "the wages the employee is entitled to receive" each week, and "wages" in s. 1 excludes "any sums paid as gifts or bonuses that are dependent on the discretion of the employer and that are not related to hours, production or efficiency". Those two conditions are cumulative, so a formula driven bonus is not obviously inside the exclusion. Your stronger route for a bonus is usually the common law claim, where active employment and good standing wording has repeatedly failed at the Court of Appeal, including in Andros v. Colliers Macaulay Nicolls Inc., 2019 ONCA 679.

I was given 6 months of working notice. Does section 60 protect the whole 6 months?

No. The definition of "statutory notice period" in s. 1 has two limbs. Limb (a) is the notice required under Part XV. Limb (b) applies where the employer gives more notice than required, and it protects only "that part of the notice period ending with the termination date specified in the notice which equals the period of notice required under Part XV". With 6 months of working notice and 8 weeks of statutory entitlement, the s. 60 protections attach to the final 8 weeks. A tranche vesting in month two has to be argued on common law grounds instead.

About the Author
Daniel Carter

Daniel Carter

Legal Writer, Mirza Law

Daniel Carter is a legal writer at Mirza Law in Toronto. He writes about layoffs, employment contracts, and the steps to take before you sign anything from your employer.

See all articles

Whenever you're ready, we're here.

Prefer to call?(289) 272-2412

Let's Connect