Is Long-Term Disability Taxable in Ontario?
Whether your long-term disability benefits are taxable comes down to one thing: who paid the premiums. Here is how to tell, and what it means for your cheque.
Key takeaways
- Whether your LTD benefits are taxable depends almost entirely on who paid the premiums.
- If your employer paid the premiums, your monthly LTD benefits are taxable income.
- If you paid the premiums with after-tax dollars, your benefits are tax-free.
- A lump-sum settlement of an LTD claim has its own tax treatment and is worth planning before you accept.
- Tax aside, if your LTD claim was denied, that is a separate legal problem you may be able to fight.
In this article
Long-term disability benefits replace part of your income when you cannot work, so the tax question matters a lot: it is the difference between keeping all of your cheque or losing a chunk to tax. The answer in Ontario comes down to a single question, and it is not the one most people expect.
✅Quick answer. It depends on who paid the premiums. If your employer paid for the LTD coverage, your benefits are taxable. If you paid the premiums yourself with after-tax money (common in group plans where the premium comes off your paycheque, or in a private policy), your benefits are tax-free. Same benefit, very different take-home, based on who funded it.
Is long-term disability taxable in Ontario?
There is no single yes or no. LTD benefits are taxable only when the premiums were paid by your employer and not treated as a taxable benefit to you. When you fund the premiums yourself, the Canada Revenue Agency treats the benefits as a return of your own insured money, so they are not taxed. This is why two people on the same plan can have very different after-tax incomes.
Employer-paid premiums: your benefits are taxable
If your employer pays the LTD premiums as part of your benefits package, the monthly benefit you receive is taxable income, much like a paycheque. Tax may be withheld at source by the insurer. This is the most common surprise: people assume disability money is always tax-free, then find their benefit is smaller than expected after tax.
Employee-paid premiums: your benefits are tax-free
If you pay the premiums yourself with after-tax dollars, whether through a group plan where the premium is deducted from your net pay, or through a private individual policy you bought, your LTD benefits are tax-free. You keep the full amount. This is one reason it can be worth paying your own LTD premiums where you have the choice.
| Who paid the LTD premiums | Are the benefits taxable? |
|---|---|
| Employer paid (a benefit to you) | Yes, taxable income |
| You paid, with after-tax dollars | No, tax-free |
| A private policy you bought yourself | No, tax-free |
| Premiums split / unclear | Depends, check the plan |
How do you find out who paid the premiums?
Check your benefits booklet or plan summary, look at whether LTD premiums appear as a deduction on your pay stub, and ask your HR department or the insurer directly. If you receive a tax slip (such as a T4A) for the benefits, that is a sign they are being treated as taxable. When it is genuinely unclear, it is worth getting it confirmed, because it changes your real income.
What about a lump-sum LTD settlement?
If you settle an LTD dispute for a lump sum instead of ongoing monthly payments, the tax treatment is more complicated and depends on what the settlement represents and how it is structured. Some portions can be taxable and others not. Because the structure affects how much you keep, it is worth getting tax and legal advice before you sign a settlement, not after.
What if your LTD claim was denied?
Tax is only relevant if you are actually receiving benefits. Insurers deny valid LTD claims often, and a denial is not the final word. You may be able to appeal or sue the insurer, and there are strict time limits, including limitation periods in the policy itself, so do not wait. If you were also let go around the same time, see fired while on medical leave. You can get a free review of your situation.
📌General information, not tax advice. This explains the general rules. Your own situation can turn on the fine print of your plan, so confirm the details with the insurer and, for the numbers, a tax professional.
Frequently asked questions
Are long-term disability benefits taxable in Canada?
It depends on who paid the premiums. If your employer paid them, the benefits are taxable. If you paid them with after-tax dollars, the benefits are tax-free. The same rule applies across Canada, including Ontario.
Why is my LTD benefit being taxed?
Most likely because your employer paid the premiums, which makes the monthly benefit taxable income. The insurer may withhold tax at source. Check your plan to confirm who funded the premiums.
Is a lump-sum disability settlement taxable?
It varies with what the settlement represents and how it is structured. Parts may be taxable and parts not. Get tax and legal advice before accepting a lump sum so you understand what you will actually keep.
My LTD claim was denied. Can I do anything about the tax question?
Tax only matters once you are receiving benefits. If your claim was denied, the priority is challenging the denial, which often succeeds. There are strict deadlines, so get advice quickly.
Omar Haddad
Legal Writer, Mirza Law
Omar Haddad is a legal writer at Mirza Law in Toronto. He writes about termination, medical and disability leave, and what the law protects when an employee is let go.
See all articles
